Emotional Support for Patients With Depression

Depression is regarded as a major global public health problem it affects all types of people in all cultures a cross the world, and is the cause of substantial suffering and disability Worldwide.

Depression is fourth leading cause of disability .Depression is predicted to be the second leading cause of disability in the year (2020) the disability also increases with severity of the depression. The World Health Organization (2006) established that over the past45 years, suicide rates had increased by60% worldwide and that suicide was the third most common cause of death for both men and women between the ages of 15 and 44 years demonstrating a change from earlier figures where older people were the most likely group to commit suicide. The World Health Organization (2006) stated that depression was the cause for approximately 90percentage of all cases of suicide (Hansson, 2010).

Depression

Is a common mental health disorder that often presents with depressed mood, loss of interest or pleasure feeling of guilt or low self worth, disturbed sleep, loose of appetite, low energy and poor concentration. As result, these problems can become chronic or recurrent and lead to substantial impairments in the individual’s ability to take care of his or her everyday responsibilities (WHO, 2011).Genetics and neuroscience research and other research studies have shown that depressive illnesses are disorders of the brain. Yet, the exact causes for these illnesses are not yet clear and are still being studied. Imaging technologies such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans show that the brains of people with depression look different from those of people without the illness. The scans show that the areas of the brain that control moods, thinking, sleep, appetite and behavior are not functioning properly (National institutes of health, 2007).

There are many causes of depression such as a reaction to life event( i.e.) death of a loved one, breakdown of relationship, financial worries, stressful events in person life and difficult childhood experiences are leading to depression in adulthood (Walsh, 2009).

There are also genetic causes such as family history of disease, there are biochemical causes such as changes in hormones and there are chemical imbalances psychological causes such as social, anxiety, stress. As well as there are serious medical illnesses like, diabetes, cancer, Parkinson’s disease, in addition to the causes there are some medication which are taken for these illnesses may cause side effects that contribute to depression (National institutes of health, 2007).

Types of depressions

There are many types of depressions described.


  • Major depressive disorder (MDD) in old age

It is associated with increased volumes of visceral fat, which is also known as organ fat is located inside the peritoneal cavity ,packed in between internal organs as opposed to subcutaneous fat which is found underneath the skin and intramuscular fat which is found interspersed in skeletal muscle (Anderson, Anderson, 2006).

As well as a high prevalence of the metabolic syndrome, this is a cluster of metabolic derangements that are associated with primary disturbances in adipose tissue (Potenza, &Mechanic 2009).It is characterized by at least 2 weeks of depressed mood or loose of interest in pleasure consists of a single episode as recurrent major depression at various points in life often it begins between ages 18 and 45 (Major depression,2009).The symptoms can be very sever can also include psychosis, psychosis mean a person has lost the ability to distinguish between what is real and what is not real. A person can experience hallucinations. Moreover, hallucinations are when major depressive disorder person sees things that are not there or hears voices (Kneisal, Wilson&Trigoboff)


  • Major depression episode

It is mood of disturbance characterized by sadness and grief is resulting from personal loss, tragedy, or loss of interest in activities (Kneisl, Wilson & Trigoboff, 2004).


  • Dysthymic disorder

It requires a chronically depressed mood for the at least two years symptoms tend to be less severe than in major depressed disorder(Kneisl, Wilson & Trigoboff, 2004).


  • Seasonal affective disorder

Seasonal affective disorder, it is also called (SAD) that triggered by the season of the year the symptoms begin in the winter and end by summer (Kneisl, Wilson&Trigoboff, 2004).


  • Bipolar disorder

Are group of mood disorders that include manic episode, hypomanic episodes, depressed episodes and cyclothymiacs disorder. Bipolar disorders tend to be recurrent decreasing in frequenancy as the individual age’s most bipolar 1 disorder clients return to normal functioning (Kneisl, Wilson&Trigoboff, 2004).


  • Mood disorder due to other conditions

It is manifested by physiological conditions mood disorder due to a general medical condition such as hepatitis it may also induced by substance abuse such as cocaine or prescribed medication like antihypertensive or oral contraceptive (Kneisl, Wilson&Trigoboff, 2004).


  • Postpartum mood episodes (PPME)

Almost 50% of women experience it is occurs from 2 weeks to 1 year following the birth of the child (Kneisl, Wilson&Trigoboff, 2004).

Diagnosing depression

The (DSM-IV) the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders is probably the most widely consulted classification system in psychiatry. Its provides a system for the classification of all mental disorders, including differential diagnosis, with a coding system for each disorder for record-keeping purposes. The manual is designed to guide diagnosis in clinical practice (Barker, 2009). Moreover, the important step in getting appropriate treatment is visit a doctor or the mental health professional, he or she will exclude the case of the other medical cause of depression by doing the complete physical exam and interview and laboratory tests.

The mental health professional will ask about the history of symptoms, such as when it started and how they have lasted a long time, whether signed before, whether they were treated. Hence, the mental health professional will diagnose depression then the most appropriate treatment will be choose and to be start (National institutes of health, 2007). There are many screening instrument are used in diagnosis of depression such as the Zung self-rating depression scale (WHO, 2011) The GDS- scoring sheets (Walsh, 2009).

Psychiatric unit

Patient who are in need of psychiatric care for depression are often admitted to psychiatric unit for treatment of in-patient who requires psychiatric care (Anderson, Anderson, 2006).

Role of the nurse

According to American Nurses Association psychiatric mental health is specialized area that includes the continues and comprehensive primary mental health care services in promoting of optimal mental health and preventing of mental illness.Hence,self awareness,empathy,emotional support and moral integrity all enable the psychiatric nurse to practice the use of self artfully in therapeutic relationships(Kneisl,Wilson&Trigoboff,2004).

The Depression Nurse Specialist (DNS) plays a key role in initially assessing symptoms of depression, educating and activating patients, providing feedback on patients progress to their primary care clinician, helping to implement treatment plans, and monitoring patients to improve their compliance with their treatment regimen. Moreover, the care is consisting of face -to face patient supervision, and communication (RAND, 2010).A major goal for nursing is to provide the high level of physical care that it currently meet the needs of the patients holistically. Patient who receive holistic care generally do much better than those who do not. It is also well documented that those with a good support group, which provides good emotional, psychological and social, spiritual help do much better than those without it. To integrate the above to provide best practice advice on the care of people with depression and their family and careers (Anderson, et el. 2010).

Jean Watson theory of human caring influenced by Jungian psychology, feminist theory caring healing within Watson framework is based on values like, kindness, love of self and others

A humanistic altruistic value system faith hope and sensitivity of self and others. Therefore, her theory emphasizes sensitivity of self and values clarification regarding personal and cultural beliefs. As a result, she credits much of her thinking on therapeutic relationship and communication to work indentifying congruency, empathy and warmth as foundational to a caring relationship that expression of emotion Watson develops the notion of spiritual environmental and the interconnectedness of all things. (Kneisl, Wilson&Trigoboff, 2004).

Emotional support

Emotional support is regarded as a sensitive under-standing approach that helps patients accept and deal with their illnesses. This includes that the patient have the to communicate their anxieties and fear, drive comfort from a gentle, sympathetic caring person and increase their ability to care for themselves (Anderson, Anderson, 2006).

Nursing management

Nursing management of patients suffering from depression generally includes emotional support. Emotional support involves facing the patients as individuals, increasing their feelings of safety, reducing their anxieties and increasing the patients trust and faith in the future. Patient typically experience painful thoughts and emotional such as fear, grief, confusion, shame embarrassment and guilt. Patients are often afraid of losing control of themselves or of being viewed as weak for expressing their felling (Keltner, Schwecke & Bostrom, 2007).In general most patient desire to have someone to support them emotionally. In fact, many hospital have a counseling service, many patients feel more comfortable with the nurse who provides emotional support and care to them. Thus, the nurse is the most available person to question and to seek support from, so this is a natural desire (Lee, 2009).

Aim

To explore the impact of emotional support given by the nurse to patients with a diagnosis of depression, in a psychiatric unit.

Research questions

How dose emotional support affect the patient outcome?

By giving emotional support to the patient, how does this affect the nurse?

Do all patients with depression in a psychiatric unit need emotional support?

METHOD

A literature review is the method chosen for this study. “A literature review is a critical summary of research on a topic of interest, often prepared to put a research problem in context” (Polit&Beck, 2008).

The authors will analyse between 15-25 articles by reading them and exchanging the articles

Between the authors, and then highlight the similar words, which were like, depression using the following tools during the research for data collection.”Literature review which is critical summary of research on a topic of interest, often prepared to put a research problem in context” (Polit&beck, 2008).

PubMed

During the author searching, we use PubMed, “which is a database that anyone, anywhere in the world with internet access can search for journal articles and permanent resource regardless of your institutional affiliation” (Polit&Beck, 2008).

CINAHL

It is regarded as an important electronic database for nurses its covers references to virtually all English language nursing and allied health journals. In addition to provide, bibliographic information for locating references (i.e. the author, title, journal, year of publication volume and page number). (Polit&Beck, 2008).

Mesh term (key word)

Depression, Depressions type, emotional support.

Data collection

Inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria

The PubMed and CINAHL are used in this study to search for academic article and all in English language. The authors will include the old age 56 and above patient with major depression disorder in the hospital especially in psychiatric unit. The authors will exclude the cases without major depression disorder and young ages under 56.

ETHICALS CONSIDERATIONS

Ethical consideration is known as moral values of the method, procedures, perspective and how to analyze problems and issues (Polit&Beck, 2008).The authors must consider the ethical issues, in the articales, which were approved by the ethical committee. According to(National Institute of Environment Health Sciences,2010) the research ethic are honesty, objectivity, integrity, carefulness,respect,and they used the justices when they did their survey. The authors avoid any misconduct such as fabrication, falsification or plagiarism in reviewing the research (Polit&Beck, 2008).

REFERENCES.

Anderson, I., Pilings., Barres, A., Bayliss, l., Bird., Burbeck,R.,Graham,C.,,C. Clarke., Dyer., Flanagag,E., Harris., Hopkins,S., et el. (2010). Depression the treatment and management of depression in adult. (Update edition). London. The British psychological society and the royal college of psychiatrists.

Anderson, K., N. &Anderson, L., E. (2006) Mosby pocket dictionary of nursing medicine and professions allied to medicine (UK edition).England. International limited.

Barker, P., (2009). Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing the craft of caring (2th ed.). United Kingdom. Hodder Arnold.

Chiu, E., (2004).Epidemiology of depression in Asia pacific region. Bulletin of Royal Australian and New Zealand College of psychiatrists. 12 suppal: S4-10.

Greggersen, W.,RUDORF,S., Fassbinder,E.,Dibbeh,L.,Stoeckelhuber,BM., Hohagen,F., Oltmans,KM.,KG.,Schwiger,U., et el .(2011).Major depression,bordeline personality disorder ,and visceral fat content in women. European Archives psychiatry and clinic neuroscience

.DOI:10, 1007/ s 00406- 0194-6.

Hansson .M., (2010).Depression in primary care Detection, treatment, and patients own perspectives .Umea University, Sweden.

Kenisal, Carol., Ren. Wilson, Holly., Skodol. Trigoboff, Eileen., (2004).Contemporary psychiatric- mental health nursing (1st ed). New Jersey. Upper Saddle River.

Keltner,N.,L. Schwecke,L.,H. Bostrom,C.,E. (2007).Psychiatric Nursing .( 5th ed ).The United States of America. Mosby Elsevier.

Khandelwal, S., (2001).Conquering depression. South -East Asia .World Health Organization http://whqlibdoc.who.int/searo/2001/SEA_Ment_120.pdf.

Lee, M., L. (2009). Nursing Success in Providing Emotional Support: The Patients‟ Perspective.

Jefferson City. Meredith L. Lee. http://library.cn.edu/HonorsPDFs_2009/Lee_Meredith_L.pdf

Lindstran,A., Bergstorm,S., Rosling, H., Rubenson,B., Stenson,B., Tylleskar,T., et al (2010).Global health : An introductory text book . United state of America. Student litterateur AB Lund, Sweden

Major depression (2009).what is depression. Retrieved on March 9.2011 from http://www.epigee.org/mental_health/depression.html

National Institute of Environmental Health Science (2010).What is Ethics in Research& Why is Important? Retrieved March 15,2010,fromhttp://www.niehs.nih.gov/research/resources/bioethics/whatis.cfm

NIH Senior Health (2007) .Depression .Retrieved on March 4.2011 from http://nihseniorhealth.gov/depression/causesandriskfactors/01.html

Polit, D., F. & Beck, C., T. (2008). Nursing Research: Generating and Assessing Evidence for Nursing Practice (8th Ed.). Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.

Potenza, M., V. &Mechanic, J., I. (2009) .The metabolic syndrome definition global impact and pathophysiology.Nutrioin in clinic practice.24 (5): 56-77.

Rand (2010). Objective analysis effective .Retrieved on MARCH 3.2011 fromhttp://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1198z2.html

Walsh, L., (2009). Depression care across the lifespan. (1st ed). United Kingdom. John Wiley & Sons.

World Health Organization. (2011). Depression. Retrieved on March.4, 2011 from http://www.who.int/mental_health/management/depression/definition/en/

World Health Organization. (2011) Suicide. Retrieved on March.9, 2011 from http://www.who.int/topics/suicide/en

World Health Organization. (2011).The Zungset rating depression.Retrived on March 19, 2011 from http://www.who.int/substance_abuse/research_tools/zungdepressionscale/en/

Panayiotopoulos Syndrome in a 3 Year Old Child


Benign occipital epilepsy of childhood -Panayiotopoulos syndrome- in a 3 year old child

Menon Narayanankutty Sunilkumar *, Vadakut Krishnan Parvathy

Department of Pediatrics, Amala Institute of Medical Sciences, Amala Nagar, Thrissur-680 555, Kerala, India

  • M N Sunil Kumar
  • V K Parvathy

Running title:

Panayiotopoulos syndrome in a 3 year old child

Manuscript type: Case study


* Author for correspondence,

Dr. Menon Narayanankutty Sunilkumar


ABSTRACT

Panayiotopoulos syndrome (PS) is a relatively frequent and benign epileptic syndrome seen in children in the age group of 3-6 years and is characterised by predominantly autonomic symptoms and/or simple motor focal seizures followed or not by impairment of consciousness. Although multifocal spikes with high amplitude sharp-slow wave complexes at various locations can be present in the EEG, interictal electroencephalogram (EEG) in children with this particular type of epilepsy characteristically shows occipital spikes. This syndrome has known to be a masquerader and can imitate gastroenteritis, encephalitis, syncope, migraine, sleep disorders or metabolic diseases. In the absence of thorough knowledge of types of benign epilepsy syndromes and their various clinical presentations, epilepsy such as PS can be easily missed. The peculiar aspects of this type of epilepsy in children should be known not only by paediatricians but also by general doctors because a correct diagnosis would avoid aggressive interventions and concerns on account of its benign outcome. In this case study, we report a case of PS in a 3 year old child.


Keywords:

Benign occipital epilepsy, Panayiotopoulos syndrome, Autonomic symptoms, Emesis, EEG


I NTRO DUCTION

The International League Against Epilepsy in their expert consensus has given due importance for the various benign childhood seizures which have good prognosis.

1

PS is a common idiopathic childhood-specific seizure disorder formally recognized by the league and is included in the category of benign epilepsy syndromes and is recognized worldwide for its autonomic presentations.

2,3

This early-onset benign childhood seizures was described by Panayiotopoulos.

4

. It has been defined by Panayiotopoulos as consisting of brief, infrequent attacks or prolonged status epilepticus and characterized by ictal deviation of the eyes and/or head and vomiting, occurring in children usually between the ages of 3 and 7 years.

5

Seizures are usually followed by postictal headache and are often associated with interictal occipital rhythmic paroxysmal EEG activity that appears only after eye closure.

5

The PS has excellent prognosis and parents can be definitely reassured about its benign course

4,6,7,8,9

. The risk of developing seizure disorder in later life is negligible

6

. Detection of occipital epilepsy at very early stage is needed to successfully treat this condition and allay the fears of the parents and care givers of these children with PS.In this case report, we discuss about the occipital epilepsy in a 3 year old girl child.


CASE REPORT

A 3-year-old girl, only sibling from a poor socioeconomic family of a non-consanguineous couple, presented in the Out-patient Department of Paediatrics, Amala Institute of Medical Sciences, Thrissur, Kerala, with complaints of becoming limp after sudden episode of vomiting, followed by uprolling of eyes, stiffening of the both upper limbs and lower limbs and a brief period of drowsiness.The child was happily playing in the house about half an hour back.There was no associated fever,trauma,ear discharge ,no common paediatric illnesses like diarrhea,dysuria,cough,running nose,wheezing,throat pain.

A detailed history was taken. The child was born of a non-consanguinous parents,fullterm normal vaginal delivery,with a birth weight of 2.215 kg. She was immunized to date and had normal milestones of development.The history revealed that she had similar episodes of vomiting especially getting up from sleep and having deviation of eyes to one side,becoming limp and followed by drowsiness for few minutes in the past from the age of 1 ½ years old. Overall she had 5-6 such episodes and 3 times she had these episodes when she was sleeping.There was no associated fever during these episodes. Two times she had stiffening of all the limbs with deviation of eyes to one side,and followed by drowsiness. There was no focal type of seizures in this child. The parents attributed these to indigestion and gave home remedies as always there was vomiting and tiredness following the episodes.The child then used to play around normally. One month back the child was seen by a local doctor who advised EEG and it was done which was reported as normal and parents were advised follow up.

The child on admission was tired, but was conscious. On examination,she was afebrile,signs of meningeal irritation were absent, central nervous system examination was normal,neurocutaneous markers were absent,fundus examination was normal. Other systemic examinations were normal.Laboratory investigations showed hemoglobin (11.7 g/dl) with low indices, total leucocyte count (11,550/cumm), neutrophils (75%), lymphocytes (22%), platelets (210000/µl), ESR (35mm at1 hr),serum calcium(10 mg%),SGPT(28mg/dl),serum electrolytes levels were normal.EEG was done

(Figure- 1A and B)

and reported as symmetrically distributed normal sleep activities,with activation of rare sharp wave discharges arising from the left occipital region.An awake record could not be obtained. The diagnosis of PS was made based on the clinical history and EEG which showed the predominantly occipital spikes. She was started on carbamazepine with increasing the dose schedule to her required weight. The child did not have any allergic reaction to the drug and did not progress autonomic instability. She and her parents were given excellent emotional and pschycological supportive care,

After completion of 5 days of observation for her symptoms and any allergy to the she was discharged on day 6 with improvement in clinical conditions on multivitamins, hematinics and deworming drugs with an advice to follow-up .


DISCUSSION

PS described by Panayiotopoulos

4

is a common autonomic childhood epileptic syndrome with a significant clinical, pathophysiological characteristics and is multifocal.

10

PS is now formally recognized as a distinct clinical entity within the spectrum of benign focal epilepsies of childhood.

11

PS affects 13% of children aged 3 to 6 years who have had 1 or more afebrile seizures and 6% of such children are in the 1- to 15-year age group.

6,7,12

. Autonomic epileptic seizures and autonomic status epilepticus are the cardinal manifestations of Panayiotopoulos syndrome.

12

. The main aspect of PS is that irrespective of their location at onset, there is activation of autonomic disturbances and emesis, to which children are particularly vulnerable. These symptoms and pattern of autonomic seizures and autonomic status epilepticus in PS do not occur in adults and are very specific to childhood.

12

PS is often confused with occipital epilepsy and acute non-epileptic disorders such as encephalitis, syncope, cyclic vomiting or atypical migraine even with characteristic clinical and EEG manifestations.

13

The clinical and EEG features of PS is due to a a maturation-related diffuse cortical hyperexcitability

4,6

. This diffuse epileptogenicitywhich may be unequally distributed,is predominating in one area of the brain , and is often posterior. The explanation for the characteristic involvement of emetic and the autonomic systems may be attributed to epileptic discharges which are generated at various cortical locations andthis in turn influence the children’s vulnerable emetic centers and the hypothalamus

4,6

. The diagnosis is based entirely on clinical presentation and EEG.

12

PS has some of the key clinical features which are often present as single, focal seizures with an unusual constellation of autonomic, mainly emetic, symptoms,associated behavioral changes, and sometimes seizure like clinical manifestations such as unilateral deviation of the eyes and convulsions

3,4,7,8,9,13

. The emetic triad in PS (nausea,retching, vomiting) culminates in vomiting in 74% of the seizures; in others, only nausea or retching occurs, and in a few, vomiting may not be present. Other autonomic manifestations include pallor, , mydriasis or miosis, flushing or cyanosis thermoregulatory and cardiorespiratory alterations. Frequently incontinence of urine and/or feces, hypersalivation, cephalic sensations, and modifications of intestinal motility are also seen

9

. Half of the convulsions end with hemiconvulsions or generalized convulsions. Two thirds occur during sleep as was seen in our child for about three times.. Autonomic status epilepticus enveals then.. The seizures usually last for 5–15 min, but half of them are prolonged, sometimes for hours, constituting autonomic status epilepticus. The patient recovers within a few hours. even after the most severe seizures episodes and status.

12

An electroencephalogram is the only investigation with abnormal results, usually showing multiple spikes in various brain locations.

12

Multifocal spikes that predominate in the posterior regions characterize the EEG

6

.The EEG variability in our child of 3 years is showing the characteristic occipital spikes from the left occipital region. The EEG done 5 months back was normal in our child. PS is the second most frequent benign syndrome of childhood after rolandic epilepsy,which primarily affects 15% of children at a peak onset at age 7–9 years

1

. Another epileptic syndrome categorized with PS and rolandic epilepsy is the Gastaut type childhood occipital epilepsy

2

, manifesting with frequent and brief visual seizures. However, this is rare,of uncertain prognosis, and markedly different from PS,despite common interictal EEG manifestations of occipital spikes

6

.Occipital spikes in non-epileptic children with defective vision, occipital slow spike-and-wave found in some patients with the Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, focal epilepsy due to occipital lesions, seizures originating in the temporal lobe secondary to an occipital abnormality, and complicated or basilar migraine must be considered in the differential diagnosis.

5

There are typical and atypical case of PS

15,17,18

.Lada et al

15

conducted a retrospective study of 43 patients with PS who were seizure free >2 years. In their analysis girls predominated ,as in our child was a girl.. The first seizure was seen in 5 years of age. 86% had emesis as the symptom with the seizures. Seizures during sleep (84%) were more common than those in wakefulness. EEG showed occipital spikes in more than 50% of patients.. Prognosis was excellent and 80% children have been free of seizures for > or =2 years as is in a typical case of PS.

15


DeÄŸerliyurt

et al

16

did a case series study of patients with PS and postulated that PS is associated with high rates of febrile convulsions, afebrile convulsions/epilepsy, migraine, and breath-holding spells in the patients and families suggested the importance of genetic factors

17

.Febrile seizures are to be considered in the differential diagnosis because the recovery of consciousness from seizure is fast and Control of the seizure is paramount. uncomplicated usually.

18


Ferrie

et al.

17

postulated an atypical evolution of PS in a case report.

The management of PS is not complicated. Education and knowledge about PS is the cornerstone of management. Control of the seizure is paramount. Prophylactic treatment with antiepileptic medication may not be needed for most patients. The emphasis is on treatment of possible fever and mainly of the underlying illness.One third (30%) of the seizures are relatively brief and self-limited. They subside spontaneously within 2–10min. The other two thirds (70%) have long-lasting seizures(>10 min) or status epilepticus (>30 min to hours). These should be appropriately and vigorously treated as for status epilepticus

19,20

. Parents of children with recurrent seizures should be advised to place the child on its side or stomach on a protected surface and administer a preparation of intravenous rectal benzodiazepine (BZD). In an emergency facility, the child’s airway should be kept clear, oxygenation maintained, and intravenous or rectal antiepileptic drug (AED) given to halt the seizure. A BZD is probably the first choice. The great majority with PS do not need AED treatment even if they have lengthy seizures or have more than two recurrences. There is no increased risk of subsequent epilepsy or neurologic deficit. If a child has multiple recurrences (only about 5% exceed 10 seizures) and if the parents too worried prophylaxis can be given.Continuous prophylaxis consists of daily medication with any AED with proven efficacy in partial seizures.Although there is no evidence of superiority among monotherapy with phenobarbitone, carbamazepine(CBZ), sodium valproate or no treatment in PS, most authors prefer CBZ

14

.Our child was started on Oxcarbazepine ,a structural derivative of CBZ with no side effects since last 1 month.Autonomic status epilepticus in the acute stage needs thorough evaluation; aggressive treatment may cause iatrogenic complications including cardiorespiratory arrest.

12

The adverse reactions of the antiepileptic drugs such as severe allergic reactions ,abnormal liverfunction tests and idiosyncratic reaction should be kept in mind and monitored.

14

The prognosis of PS is excellent

4,6,7-9

. The lengthy seizures and status do not have any adverse prognostic significance, and the risk of developing epilepsy in adult life is probably no more than that of the general population

6

. One third of patients (27%) have a single seizure only, and another half (47%) have two to five seizures. Only 5% have >10 seizures, but outcome is again favorable. Remission usually occurs within 1 to 2 years from onset.

6

.


CONCLUSION

PS is a common cause of epilepsy in children and a knowledgeable doctor does not miss it. Physician education of PS and recent guidelines on epilepsy management is vital in detecting PS at very early stage, so further lifesaving interventions can be done and prevent delay in the trearment administration. Multiple antiepileptic drugs use is required in only in a small proportion of patients. Seizures in PS, like febrile convulsions, despite their excellent prognosis, are a frightening experience for the in experienced parents, who often think that their child is dead or dying. Parents of young children should have general information by the family doctor regarding PS. Parental education and a supportive group comprising the paediatrician, neurologist, nursing staff and the social worker can help and reassure these distort parents as was done in our child who is doing fine with no recurrence in the last 1 month.


ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The authors acknowledge the help of Dr Ajith TA, Professor Biochemistry, Amala Institute of Medical Sciences, Amala Nagar, Thrissur, Kerala during the preparation of the manuscript.


REFERENCES

  1. Commission on Classification and Terminology of the International League Against Epilepsy. Proposal for revised classification of epilepsies and epileptic syndromes. Epilepsia 1989;30:389–99.
  2. Engel J Jr. A proposed diagnostic scheme for people with epileptic seizures and with epilepsy: Report of the ILAE Task Force on Classification and Terminology. Epilepsia 2001;42:796–803.
  3. Berg AT, Panayiotopoulos CP. Diversity in epilepsy and a newly recognized benign childhood syndrome [Editorial]. Neurology 2000;55:1073–4.
  4. Panayiotopoulos CP. Panayiotopoulos syndrome. Lancet 2001;358:68–9.
  5. Andermann F, Zifkin B.The benign occipital epilepsies of childhood: an overview of the idiopathic syndromes and of the relationship to migraine. Epilepsia. 1998;39:S9-23.
  6. Panayiotopoulos CP. Panayiotopoulos syndrome: a common and benign childhood epileptic syndrome. London: John Libbey, 2002.
  7. Panayiotopoulos CP. Vomiting as an ictal manifestation of epileptic seizures and syndromes. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1988;51:1448–51.
  8. Caraballo R, Cersosimo R, Medina C, et al. Panayiotopoulos-type benign childhood occipital epilepsy: a prospective study. Neurology2000;55:1096–100.
  9. Kivity S, Ephraim T, Weitz R, et al. Childhood epilepsy with occipital paroxysms: clinical variants in 134 patients. Epilepsia 2000;41:1522–33.
  10. Guerrini R, Pellacani S.Benign childhood focal epilepsies.

    Epilepsia.

    2012;53::9-18.
  11. Koutroumanidis M. Panayiotopoulos syndrome: an important electroclinical example of benign childhood system epilepsy. Epilepsia. 2007;48:1044-53.
  12. Covanis A. Panayiotopoulos syndrome: a benign childhood autonomic epilepsy frequently imitating encephalitis, syncope, migraine, sleep disorder, or gastroenteritis. Pediatrics. 2006 ;118:e1237-43.
  13. Michael M, Tsatsou K, Ferrie CD. Panayiotopoulos syndrome: an important childhood autonomic epilepsy to be differentiated from occipital epilepsy and acute non-epileptic disorders. Brain Dev. 2010;32:4-9.
  14. Ferrie CD, Beaumanoir A, Guerrini R, et al. Early-onset benign occipital seizure susceptibility syndrome. Epilepsia 1997;38:285–93.

  15. Lada C

    ,

    Skiadas K

    ,

    Theodorou V

    ,

    Loli N

    ,

    Covanis A

    .A study of 43 patients with panayiotopoulos syndrome, a common and benign childhood seizure susceptibility.

    Epilepsia.

    2003;44:81-8.

  16. DeÄŸerliyurt A

    , Teber S, BektaÅŸ O,

    Senkon G

    . Panayiotopoulos syndrome: A case series from Turkey.

    Epilepsy Behav.

    2014;36:24-32.

  17. Ferrie CD

    ,

    Koutroumanidis M

    ,

    Rowlinson S

    ,

    Sanders S

    ,

    Panayiotopoulos CP

    .Atypical evolution of Panayiotopoulos syndrome: a case report.

    Epileptic Disord.

    2002;4:35-42.
  18. Knudsen FU. Febrile seizures: treatment and prognosis. Epilepsia.2000;41:2–9.
  19. American Academy of Pediatrics. Practice parameter: the neurodiagnostic evaluation of the child with a first simple febrile seizure: Provisional Committee on Quality Improvement, Subcommittee on Febrile Seizures. Pediatrics 1996;97:769–72.
  20. Mitchell WG. Status epilepticus and acute repetitive seizures in children, adolescents, and young adults: etiology, outcome, and treatment. Epilepsia 1996;37:S74–80.



Legend to figures


Figure (1A and B): EEG of the child showing the occipital spikes (arrow heads).

Impact ADHD and Autism on Education

How does ADHD and/or autism impact on the pupil, other pupils, teachers and the whole school?

Introduction and Overview

First, is to define ADHD and Autism: Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is a disorder that tampers with major parts of the brain that is related the control of a person’s attention, activity and emotions which make them appear hyper or weird. ADHD can also be considered as the poor functioning and poor communication between different areas of the brain. Autism mainly appears during the first 3 years of the child’s development and growth. It’s in relation to routines and repetition of behaviors which range from mild to severe. It doesn’t mean that autism is a damage or disease.

Jaffe-Gill et al (2008) postulate that the symptoms of ADHD will show if the section of the brain which controls hyperactivity, is not fully developed or not coordinating well with the rest of the brain and therefore it is not that the child is not able to control his behavior. Autism is not purely a genetic disorder which cannot be treated but certain reactions on the genes which are indeed affected by the external environment al factors. Autism is treatable as the important part that should be understood is, if the reactions can be flipped on, they can be as well be flipped off.

Secondly, ADHD and Autism affect children and the signs and symptoms expose themselves in many different forms. The three major areas which most of the symptoms are categorized in are; in attention, hyperactivity and impulsivity. It becomes clinical when the impulsiveness and hyperactivity go beyond the social norms. The child may have difficulty in paying attention, may be fidgety, gets easily distracted, may not be able to sit still, may have difficulty in doing homework, chores around the house, or may be disorganized.

Consequently, the hyperactive-impulsive type AHDH symptoms include; being always ‘on the go’, struggles to wait in line, always fidgeting or squirming, running or climbing in excess, Struggles to remain seated, Blurts out answer before hearing question, talks too much, Struggles with interrupting or intruding and lastly they cannot play quietly. The last of the AHDH types is the combined type. This is the common of the three and it is a combination of the inattentive type and the hyperactive-impulsive type. Before a parent or teacher gets to establish an AHDH case, they may feel that the child is acting out or seeking attention. Without medication or/and behavioural therapy a child struggles to control his or her behaviour.

Other signs of ADHD are shown when the child gets so disruptive or fidgety in class that interferes with the teacher as she tries to teach the other students, the student blurt out answers in class, the student find sit hard to wait for his turn in the line, the child also becomes so hyperactive that he cannot sit through a session for instance, the church service or watching a movie. With autism the three core areas that are involved or show the signs of the disorder include; social-not socially interacting with the environment and just being by themselves, communication which is manifested by the age of 3 when a delay in speech is eminent, and repetitive movements or limited interest.

Fact file on ADHD

There are various facts about Autism and ADHD:

On ADHD, it affects between 5 to 10% of the school going children and affects more boys than girls about 3 to 4 times more, another fact is that 50 to 60 % of the children will continue to experience the symptoms throughout to adulthood, the ones which need pediatric prescriptions are about 78%. Many cases of ADHD are reported worldwide, especially those that affect children below the age of 3 years (Fuller, 2008). This is the year that is said to be when Autism and ADHD manifest and begin to show up prominently.

On Autism; 1 in every 150 children are diagnosed with autism while 1 in every 94 boys has the disorder. It is further evident that each day, about 67 children are diagnosed with the Autism disorder and a new case is reported every 20 minutes. In comparison to AIDS, diabetes, & cancer, it is further true according to statistics that more children will be diagnosed with autism this shows that it is the most rapidly growing acute developmental disability in the U.S. boys are expected to have autism four times more. There is neither cure nor medical detection for autism.

Since ADHD and Autism affect the school going children, and they spend at least eight hours everyday in school, the teachers and students are more likely to observe the change in behaviors in the students and hence a big impact will be felt within the school and its environment. This document will look at the impacts of autism on pupil, on other pupils, on teachers and on the whole school.

Impact of Autism on Pupil

Children with severe speech difficulties finding it difficult to communicate may become very frustrated. They may be reluctant to communicate or may refuse to do so at all. If required to communicate, they may show signs of intense stress or anxiety. The child may have low self esteem and may feel rejected by peers (and may in fact be rejected by some). In such circumstances, it may become difficult to recognize that.

Without support, the child may develop behavioral, emotional and social difficulties. This appears to be supported by evidence of communication problems among population such as children in care and pupils in school.

Because of their dependence on structure, major problems can arise for children with autism outside lesson times. Although breaks from lessons are designed to provide normal children with the opportunities they need to relax and to interact with their peers, for a child with autism such period can be extremely stressful, children who are able to behave quite acceptably when involved in guided and structured activities frequently appear much more ‘odd’ or unusual at times of free play.

Stereotyped and ritualistic behaviors may become more apparent and exposure to teasing or bullying is much more of a risk, especially because staff supervision at such times is greatly reduced. Break times are designed to reduce the pressure from the children not increase and therefore by allowing the children with autism to go for the break will just increase the amount of pressure in them thus it would be good if they are not allowed to go but instead relax in class by themselves without any disturbance.

School meals can be another source of difficulty and it is clear from personal accounts that having to tolerate the noise and smells of meals in a crowded school canteen can be almost akin to torture for individuals with autism. Been forced into close proximity with other students, or made to eat food of particular textures or mixed together on the plate (many individuals cannot bear separate items of food touching each other) can be extremely stressful.

Clare Sainsbury writes: (the potential of making mistakes (and the anxiety caused by fear of making mistakes) is enormous. One of my most vivid memories of secondary schools is been hauled out of the lunch queue by one of the dinner ladies shouting angrily, and made to stand to one side; she refused to tell me why. Only after I had burst into tears was I allowed back….nobody ever explained what I had done wrong….and to this day I still have no idea.)

A quiet corner in which to eat, being allowed to eat slightly earlier or later than other pupils, or being permitted to bring sandwiches are among the simple solutions that can transform a nightmare into a practicable tolerant activity. If the principal problem is lack of knowledge of what to do when the basic rules can be explained simply – and discreetly- beforehand. Games and extracurricular lessons are also frequent causes of stress for pupils with autism, who may lack the motor coordination, the ability to follow rapid instructions or unwritten rules and the social reciprocity required in order to contribute to these activities in any useful way.

Competitive sports are a particular problem and are probably best avoided altogether, both for the sake of the person with autism and the rest of the class. However, physical fitness can be improved by encouraging activities that improve body awareness and coordination such as yoga, swimming, golf, walking or gymnastics if sensitively taught.

Impact of Autism on Other Pupils

The impact of Autism on other pupils can be as a result of the reaction of the children affected by Autism (Autistics). Due to the hyperactivity, in them, the other pupils will develop fear in them as they will seem as a threat to them. For instance, if a child is the kind who throws things around when annoyed, will make his classmates scream, run away, there may be accidents in that a child can be hit by the furniture or the object thrown around.

Autistics are also known to be bright and understand things so fast, besides their self esteem was lowered by other students, they can also lower other pupils self esteem in academics especially. This is so because the weaker ones will be teased by them and feel threatened instead. In many cases, if the teacher does not realize this early enough, she may have ea tendency of rushing through the syllabus since of the assumption that if one or two pupils have understood what is been taught, the rest will learn from them.

For some children this lack of understanding may result in a refreshing acceptance of the child with autism for the person they are. However, some children may be fearful and this may result in ostracizing, bullying, or mocking the children with autism (Kinsley, 2008). These attitudes create a matrix of difficulties for the child with the disorder which exacerbates their already significant impairments in forming peer relationships.

Impact of Autism on Teachers

According to Folin and Lian (2008), a teacher’s attitude towards pupils with Autism is directly related to the knowledge and understanding of the condition. Consequently, there is a need to develop systems and means by which knowledge and understanding about Autism are share with other colleagues. Understandably, we are in competition with multitude of other demands on professionals and, therefore, need to promote information, in an accessible and manageable form which is tailored to the context they are working in. the depth of knowledge required might lie on a continuum from awareness to expertise by the role they perform.

Colleagues whose only contact with pupils with autism is during break times or assemblies will need a different level of understanding to those colleagues who may share the same teaching space. Similarly, these colleagues’ needs will differ again from the people primarily responsible for the teaching of youngsters with Autism. Responding to this continuum of professional development need, the training portfolio may include: Informal approaches, inset days, outreach, accredited courses, and resources.

Each of these depends upon practitioners within the field promoting the cause of pupils with the disorder in a positive and proactive manner.

Impact of Autism on the Whole School

A major impact in the whole school would be loosing children due to parents transferring their children to other schools because of various reasons such bullying. There has been case from various schools of major bullying taking place within the school; educators and society are concerned about the violent attacks in the schools (Schultz, n.d.). It is imperative that there should be a school-wide bullying prevention programs. This program will be specially tailored to address all issues that come along with the ADHD and Autism pupils.

Bullying is pervasive, in the schools and adults ought to be at the forefront in bullying. This is basically because a lot of pupils will lose out especially if they are bullied until it affects their academics. It is further recommended that the right academic modification as well as academic adaptation is incorporated into the school program. The law generally requires that every child should be provided with proper and a safe learning environment. Every school should thus have the facilities for special education of the children with Autism. Compliance to these standards should be ensured on a constant basis.

Conclusion

ADHD and Autism are disorders that affect parts of the brain. They are not purely genetic and can be controlled. Measures should be taken to create a good environment for both the children that need special attention and the other children and also the school environment. ADHD and Autism therefore affects the children’s ability to learn. This in itself means that there are various learning activities that the students with Autism will have to miss out on, thus impacting negatively on their performance in class. Whenever the class performance deeps, the school’s overall performance will also dip in a similar fashion.

To sum it up, the pupil with ADHD and Autism will learn slowly thus impeding their ability to keep up to pace with the rest. Their performance will also be negative with minimal or negative advancement. Similarly, the other pupils will find it difficult to be taught at the same pace as the pupil with ADHD and Autism (Sprinkle, 2004). When their learning is affected, they will have to also exhibit withdraw signs as well as lose interest in the subject being taught. On the other hand, the teachers will find it very strenuous so that they will develop an attitude that will affect their teaching patterns. Eventually this translates into poor school performance and loss of reputation as a result. Therefore, the school will suffer from adverse publicity from the critics. Likewise, the school will be compelled to expend large sums of money in setting up a unit specially meant for the ADHD and Autism pupils.

References

Folin, C., & Lian, M.J. (2008). Reform, inclusion, and teacher education: towards a new era of special education in the Asia-Pacific region. New York: Routledge. Retrieved October 06, 2009 from http://books.google.co.ke/books?id=X0rfLl87vkcC&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_navlinks_s#v=onepage&q=&f=false

Fuller, J. (2008). How to Use Behavior Modifications to Treat Childhood ADHD. eHow.

Retrieved October 06, 2009 from http://www.ehow.com/how_4607436_behavior-modifications-treat-childhood-adhd.html

Jaffe-Gill, E., Smith, M., Segal, R., & Segal, J. (2008). Behavior Therapy for

ADD/ADHD. Retrieved October 06, 2009 from http://www.vaxa.com/behavioral-treatment-adult.cfm

Kinsley, R.S. (2008). What Is ADHD? KidsHealth.com. Retrieved October 06, 2009 from

http://kidshealth.org/PageManager.jsp?dn=KidsHealth&lic=1&ps=107&cat_id=146&article_set=21612

Schultz, J.J. (n.d.). Behavior Modification Instead of Medication? Retrieved October 06,

2009 from http://school.familyeducation.com/add-and-adhd/medical-treatment/42677.html

Sprinkle, N. (2004). ADHD Behavior Therapy: Promoting Discipline & Focus in Kids.

Additudemag.com. Retrieved October 06, 2009 from http://www.additudemag.com/adhd/article/860.html

Discuss the current state of health care quality, as well as efforts to measure and improve quality.

Discuss the current state of health care quality, as well as efforts to measure and improve quality.

Order Description

To prepare:
Readings
Kovner, A. R., & Knickman, J. R. (Eds.). (2011). Health care delivery in the United States (Laureate Education, Inc., custom ed.). New York, NY: Springer Publishing.
Chapter 11, “High Quality Health Care” (pp. 233–255)

This chapter discusses the current state of health care quality, as well as efforts to measure and improve quality.
Chapter 14, “Governance, Management, and Accountability” (pp. 299–313)

This chapter details the vital importance of developing a better understanding of why and how heath care organizations are governed and managed in order to improve accountability.
Berwick, D. (2005). My right knee. Annals of Internal Medicine, 142(2), 121–125.
Retrieved from the Walden Library databases.

In this article, Donald Berwick describes five specific dimensions of “total quality” care he will need when his right knee is replaced; however, he feels no one health care institution can deliver all five dimensions.
Gardner, D. (2010). Health policy and politics. Expanding scope of practice: Inter-professional collaboration or conflict? Nursing Economic$, 28(4), 264–266.
Retrieved from the Walden Library databases.

This article summarizes the interdisciplinary conflict and collaboration likely to be promoted by the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. The text emphasizes the value of mediators in facilitating discussions between thought leaders from different disciplines.
Solomon, P. (2010). Inter-professional collaboration: Passing fad or way of the future? Physiotherapy Canada, 62(1), 47–55.
Retrieved from the Walden Library databases.

This lecture highlights challenges to collaborative practice in clinical settings. In addition, the author presents strategies for influencing an environment to be more collaborative.
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (n.d.). Model public report elements: A sampler. Retrieved from https://www.ahrq.gov/professionals/quality-patient-safety/quality-resources/value/pubrptsampler/pubrptsampler.pdf

This web page defines the six domains that are important for health care quality. The goals of the six domains in health care to be safe, effective, patient-centered, timely, efficient, and equitable.
American Nurses Association. (n.d.) Expert policy analysis. Retrieved March 22, 2012, from https://www.nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/Policy-Advocacy/Positions-and-Resolutions/Issue-Briefs

This web page explores ANA’s Department of Nursing Practice and Policy efforts with internal policy decisions and nursing’s input on external policy.
American Nurses Association. (n.d.) Health care policy. Retrieved March 22, 2012, from https://www.nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/HealthcareandPolicyIssues.aspx

This web page informs about nurses’ firsthand experiences in effecting health care laws and regulations through ANA’s principles.
American Nurses Association. Health system reform. Retrieved March 22, 2012, from https://www.nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/Policy-Advocacy/HealthSystemReform

This web page details health reforms impact on health care delivery.
Berwick, D. (2002). Escape fire: Lessons for the future of health care. Retrieved from https://www.commonwealthfund.org/usr_doc/berwick_escapefire_563.pdf

This influential speech, given by Dr. Donald Berwick in 1999, uses the analogy of starting a fire to escape a fire as a way to detail the challenges the health care industry faces in improving the quality of care and safety.
Federal Register. (2011). Retrieved from https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collection.action?collectionCode=FR

This website houses the official daily publication of rules, proposed rules, and notices of federal agencies and organizations, including executive orders and presidential documents.
Institute of Medicine of the National Academies. (2012). Crossing the quality chasm: The IOM Health Care Quality Initiative. Retrieved from
http://www.iom.edu/Global/News%20Announcements/Crossing-the-Quality-Chasm-The-IOM-Health-Care-Quality-Initiative.aspx

The Institute of Medicine provides a Quality Initiative to document the seriousness of the quality problem and assesses the ongoing effort to improve the nation’s quality of care.
National Quality Forum (2007). Tracking NQF-endorsed consensus standards for nursing-sensitive care: A 15-month study. Washington, DC: National Quality Forum. Retrieved from https://www.qualityforum.org/Projects/s-z/Tracking_Nursing-Sensitive_Care_Consensus_Standards_%282007%29/Tracking_Nursing-Sensitive_Care_Consensus_Standards.aspx

This report provides full detail of the first comprehensive effort to evaluate the degree NQF-endorsed standards for nursing-sensitive care have been implemented.
National Quality Forum. (2012). Retrieved from https://www.qualityforum.org/Home.aspx

Review this week’s Learning Resources, focusing on the Six Aims for Improvement presented in the landmark report “Crossing the Quality Chasm: The IOM Health Care Quality Initiative.”
Consider these six aims with regard to your current organization, or one with which you are familiar. In what areas have you seen improvement? What areas still present challenges? As a nurse leader, how can you contribute to improving the organization’s achievement of these aims?
Select one specific quality or safety issue that is presenting a challenge in the organization. Consider at least one quality improvement strategy that could be used to address the issue, as well as which of the six aims for improvement would then be addressed.
Reflect on your professional practice and your experiences with inter-professional collaboration to improve quality and safety. How has inter-professional collaboration contributed to your organization’s efforts to realize the IOM’s six aims for improving health care? Where has inter-professional collaboration been lacking?

Post a description of the quality or safety issue you selected and a brief summary of the impact that this issue has on health care delivery. Describe at least one quality improvement strategy used to address this issue. Then explain which of the six “aims for improvement” are addressed by the strategy. Finally, explain how inter-professional collaboration helps improve quality in this area.

Cardiovascular Disease Rates in Australia


Background

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is one of the main causes of disability and premature mortality worldwide (Lopez et al., 2006) and it significantly affects the costs of healthcare. CVD has been reported to be a leading cause of mortality in Australia with around 29% of deaths attributable to CVD in 2015 (ABS, 2016). In 2008-09, CVD represented 12% of the total health expenditure in Australia and rates of hospital-related patient services for CVD have increased between 2001-08 and is continuing to increase (AIHW, 2014). CVD encompasses a range of conditions including coronary artery disease (includes myocardial infarction), stroke, hypertension or congestive heart failure. In 2014-15, it was estimated that approximately 1 in 5 Australian adults aged 18 and older have been burdened by 1 or more cardiovascular diseases (AIHW, 2018).

There are a number of modifiable health risk factors that contribute to an increased risk of CVD such as hypertension, diabetes, tobacco smoking, high blood lipid and cholesterol profile, obesity, physical inactivity and chronic alcohol consumption (Smith, 2007). Many of these risk factors are inter-related; for instance, obesity and diabetes are connected as one condition can lead to the other. Moreover, physical inactivity and obesity are linked as one does lead to the other and vice versa. Obesity can also lead to a high blood lipid and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol profile, but this could also be due to genetic factors with inborn errors in the metabolism of lipids and cholesterol. This is notable in a condition known as familial hypercholesterolaemia where individuals may lack genetic factors involved cholesterol uptake into cells, leading to elevated levels in the blood, and hence atherosclerotic plaque formation, i.e. coronary artery disease (Varghese, 2014).  On top of these, risk factors such as increasing age, family history and ethnicity increase the rate of CVD (Buttar et al., 2005). However, this list comprises risk factors that are non-modifiable. Around the world, it has been found that male gender is a non-modifiable risk factor, however, Australian statistics show that the prevalence of CVD was measured as similar between male and female adults aged 18-54. However, according to graphical data of the National Health Survey, the prevalence is observed to be greater in Australian male adults aged 55-75+, which also supports that age is a cardiovascular risk factor and this is due to physiological changes that occur to arteries over time as well as issues in metabolic processes (AIHW, 2018; Tuomilehto, 2004).

In terms of the modifiable risk factors, it was found that, in 2014-15, 14.5% of Australian adults smoked daily, and this prevalence increased in regional and remote areas of Australia and was also higher in areas containing populations of low socioeconomic status (SES) (National Cancer Control Indicators, 2017). As for diabetes, its prevalence has tripled between 1989-90 and 2014-15 to 4.7% and trends have been increasing and are expected to increase over time. The prevalence of diabetes was found to be similar by geographical location but doubled in low socioeconomic groups (AIHW, 2018). Furthermore, the Australian Bureau of Statistics reported that in 2011-12, approximately one-third of Australian adults ages 18 and older had high total cholesterol. This distribution between male and female gender was similar, however, a higher prevalence was found in Australian residents located in regional and remote areas (ABS, 2012). It has been reported that physical inactivity accounts for more than 1 in 10 (12.2%) of the burden of myocardial infarctions worldwide and interestingly, the prevalence of physical inactivity was greater than smoking (35% and 26% respectively) worldwide (Yusuf et al., 2004; Wen et al., 2014).

It is therefore evident that CVD has a highly deleterious effect on the health of Australian adults and the increasing prevalence of modifiable cardiovascular risk factors is alarming and should be addressed in order to reduce the CVD burden. It is therefore necessary to focus on a number of social determinants that contribute to the increasing prevalence of these risk factors, i.e. to understand the role and relationship of upstream ‘causes of causes’ that promote CVD. These may include social determinants such as low SES which entails low income, unemployment and poor education. Investigating these will address the health disparities seen between different demographics of Australians where there are varying degrees of CVD prevalence based on SES and geographical location as discussed above. This essay will focus on unemployment and education as key social determinants that pertain to CVD.



The social determinants relevant to CVD


Unemployment

People who are living in low socioeconomic areas have many disadvantages such as low income, poor education, low employment rates and poor housing characteristics (ABS, 2016). Although there are some preventive interventions and treatments towards reducing the risk of CVD, such as behavioural risk factors, early detection and multiple treatment options for people who are already exposed to the disease; people in low socioeconomic areas are impacted differently as they do not always have access to these options particularly with regards to limited healthcare access as people in higher socioeconomic areas (Martinez-Garcia et al., 2018). This may be attributed to the cost of healthcare, particularly private health, where low income earners or the unemployed are disadvantaged due to the inability to access these services. As a result, public healthcare systems become flooded and hence patients often will not receive optimal treatment for their condition. It was found that in 2014-15, 20% of Australians that lived in an area of low SES were 1.6 times as likely to have at least two chronic health conditions such as CVD and diabetes, compared to the demographic of people with an SES representing the highest 20% (ABS, 2015). Furthermore, in 2009-11, it was reported that Australian adults residing in areas of the lowest SES have a life expectancy that is approximately 3 years less than those in the highest areas (NHPA, 2013). As outlined above, with CVD being the leading cause of mortality worldwide and having represented nearly a third of deaths in 2015 in Australia, it can be deduced that higher rates of CVD may be a significant contributing factor to the lower life expectancy in these areas. Unemployment rates have decreased over time in Australia, yet despite this, unemployment remains a major problem in the nation (ABS, 2018). Mathers and Schofield (1998) have discussed that people who are unemployed are at a higher risk of death and being ill or disabled than those who are similar age and employed. The stress that comes with being unemployed has a large impact on a person’s physical and mental health and wellbeing (Dooley et al., 1996). Unemployment may be a result of a physical or mental illness, however, for many, it may also be the reason they have health issues. Unemployment can cause several health problems through its psychological consequences and financial issues.

In general, people with no or few qualifications or skills, who have disabilities or poor mental health, who are caregivers, who are in ethnic minority groups or, people who are excluded from groups for different reasons, are at a higher risk of being unemployed (AIHW, 2015). The negative effects that come with unemployment may mostly be the due to the significant change in an individual’s lifestyle. They go from spending time at work for a long time every week to having that time free with the stress they will have from being unemployed. These may include negative changes such as altered dietary habits, increased habitual smoking, alcohol consumption or drug use. These can subsequently compound and lead to other effects such as physical inactivity, financial problems, problems in social life and relationships and depression, which are known to be the cause of serious health problems including obesity, lung conditions such as chronic bronchitis and most importantly, CVD (Weber and Lehnert, 1997).

A study done by Kasl et al. (1980) tracked the cholesterol levels of people who were expecting to be unemployed and subsequently becoming unemployed. It was found that unemployment contributed to higher cholesterol levels through fear of loss of job or unemployment. They had found that once these individuals started working again, their cholesterol levels corrected back to what was deemed a normal level. Furthermore, numerous studies have investigated the relationship between unemployment and blood pressure. While a study done by Schnall and Landsbergis (1992) did not show any significant effects of unemployment on blood pressure levels, Janlert (1992) and Hammarstrom (1994) both showed that unemployment had a negative effect on blood pressure levels, where higher unemployment rates lead to a higher prevalence of hypertension. As discussed, hypertension and a high blood LDL cholesterol are significant risk factors for CVD and as demonstrated, unemployment leads to high blood pressure and high cholesterol levels and once individuals begin working again, these measurements restore to normal levels. It is therefore clear that unemployment may lead to an adverse health profile that are known contributors to CVD, and hence it can be implied there is an inverse association between unemployment and CVD. More specifically, the physiological burden associated with unemployment increases the likelihood that an individual may develop CVD.


Education

Having no or low education may also be an important social determinant that contributes to CVD. Reasons that may explain this include not enough knowledge of the disease to take action for treatment, and similar to unemployment; physical inactivity, stress and increased tobacco smoking and substance use. There are several studies that show the relevance between education and cardiovascular disease. A study performed in Australia by Korda et al. (2017) containing 267,153 men and women aged over 45, showed that Australians that are not educated, who leave school early or do not complete it, have over twice as much risk of having a heart attack than those with a university degree and that improved education is an important factor in reducing the socioeconomic variation in CVD. This study more specifically found that the rates of heart attacks in adults aged 45-64 years who have no education is 150% higher than people with a university degree and 70% higher than those with intermediate levels of education. Similarly, a study done in the United States looking at participants aged 38-47 years found that the risk of having cardiovascular disease was 27.9% lower for people with a college degree than people without a college degree and it was concluded that factors in early life such as education may be important in contributing to CVD risk (Loucks et al., 2012). It is clear that studies conducted in Australia and in other countries support that individuals that have received poor education may be affected by CVD later in life.

The reason unemployment and education lead to a higher CVD rate is because, as demonstrated, many of the risk factors associated with CVD such as, hypertension, high blood LDL cholesterol, physical inactivity and smoking may come with being unemployed or having received no or minimal education. These factors may also affect the individual’s ability to act for prevention, early intervention or treatment. For example, a person who is not educated in the risks of CVD may not know that they need to take preventive actions to minimise their CVD risk, and a person who is unemployed may not be able to afford to pay for their medications such as statins (cholesterol-lowering drugs) or cardiovascular procedures such as coronary artery bypass graft surgeries. Ultimately, it is evident that unemployment and education should not be neglected in Australian adults so that the overall burden caused by CVD can be minimised, therefore leading to better health outcomes in this nation.



References

  1. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2012). Australian Health Survey. Canberra.
  2. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2016). Australian Health Survey. Canberra.
  3. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2016). Census of Population and Housing: Reflecting Australia – Stories from the Census, 2016. Canberra.
  4. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2018). Labour Force, Australia. Canberra.
  5. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. (2014). Health-care expenditure on cardiovascular diseases 2008–09. Canberra: AIHW.
  6. Buttar, H.S., Li, T., Ravi, N. (2005). Prevention of cardiovascular diseases: Role of exercise, dietary interventions, obesity and smoking cessation.

    Experimental & Clinical Cardiology

    , 10, 229-249.
  7. Dooley, D., Fielding, J. and Levi, L. (1996). Health and unemployment.

    Annual Review of Public Health,

    17, 449–65.
  8. Hammarstrom, A. (1994). Health consequences of youth unemployment.

    Public Health,

    108, 403±412.
  9. Janlert, U. (1992). Unemployment and blood pressure in Swedish building labourers.

    J Intern Med

    , 231, 241±246
  10. Kasl, S.V. and Cobb, S. (1980). The experience of losing a job: some effects on cardiovascular functioning.

    Psychother Psychosom

    , 34, 88-109.
  11. Lopez, A.D., Mathers, C.D., Ezzati, M., Jamison, D.T., Murray, C.J.L. (2006). Global Burden of Disease and Risk Factors. Washington DC: World Bank and Oxford University Press.
  12. Loucks, E.B., Buka, S.L., Rogers, M.L., Liu, T., Kawachi, I., Kubzansky, L.D., Martin, L.T. and Gilman, S.E. (2012). Education and coronary heart disease risk associations may be affected by early-life common prior causes: a propensity matching analysis.

    Ann Epidemiol.

    , 22, 221-32.
  13. Martinez-Garcia, M., Salinas-Ortega, M., Estrada-Arriage, I., Hernandez-Lemus, E., Garcia-Herrera, R. and Vallejo, M. (2018). A systematic approach to analyze the social determinants of cardiovascular disease.

    PLoS One

    , 13, e0190960.
  14. National Cancer Control Indicators. (2017). Smoking prevalence – adults. Canberra.
  15. NHPA (National Health Performance Authority). (2013). Healthy communities: avoidable deaths and life expectancies in 2009–2011. Sydney: NHPA.
  16. Schnall, P.L. and Landsbergis, P.A. (1992). The impact of anticipation of job loss on psychological distress and worksite blood pressure

    . Am J Ind Med,

    21, 417±432.
  17. Smith, S.C. (2007). Multiple risk factors for cardiovascular disease and diabetes mellitus.

    American Journal of Medicine

    , 120, S3-S11.
  18. The Sax Institute: The 45 and Up Study – Questionnaires [

    Questionnaires

    ] (2016). Accessed April 2016.

  19. Tuomilehto, J. (2004). Impact of age on cardiovascular risk: implications for cardiovascular disease management.

    Artherosclero Suppl.

    , 5, 9-17.
  20. Varghese, M.J. (2014). Familial hypercholesterolemia: A review.

    Ann Pediatr Cardiol.

    , 7, 107-117.
  21. Weber, A. and Lehnert, G. (1997). Unemployment and cardiovascular disease: a causal relationship?

    Int Arch Occup Environ Health

    , 70, 153-160.
  22. Wen, C.P. and Wu, X. (2012). Stressing harms of physical inactivity to promote exercise.

    Lancet

    , 380, 192–193.
  23. Yusuf, S., Hawken, S., Ounpuu, S., Dans, T., Avezum, A., Lanas, F., Mc-Queen, M., Budaj, A., Pais, P., Varigos, J. and Lisheng, L. Effect of potentially modifiable risk factors associated with myocardial infarction in 52 countries (the INTERHEART study): case-control study.

    Lancet,

    364, 937-952

Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Strategies

INTRODUCTION

Live birth with healthy child is the ultimate goal of ART cycles. There is a complexity of interlinked events that decides the final outcome of ART. This event can be categorised as,

  1. Clinical (stimulation protocol, opu, embryo transfer, pregnancy rate etc),
  2. Patient related (age, diseases) and
  3. Laboratory (ART Lab- oocyte, sperm, embryo, media, etc).

There cannot be any single thumb rule for success in any ART cycle due to numerous variations in each categories. However by setting up Key Performance Indicators (KPI) and interpreting the data statistically we can have a better understanding of our success combinations as well as flaws.

In this topic we will restrict our discussion upto laboratory category. ART lab and equipments are designed to mimic intra-uterine/ intra- fallopian tube environment. Thus by giving minimum stress to gametes a better embryo or blastocyst can be achieved which may result in healthy pregnancy. In order to have significant pregnancy rate various studies have been performed keeping in mind variables like, co2, pH, temperature, media etc. To have an insight of entire process majority of KPI are directed towards maintaining the above controls and also the clinical aspect of patient. This KPI gives us entire picture from patient age, stimulation protocols, drugs, opu, gametes, zygotes, embryos as well as record of temperature of work stations, room temperature, humidity, incubators conditions, ph, air quality , infection control policy.

Thus KPI makes us more vigilant and observes the pattern of success or failure of our lab. By using our KPI we can have customised settings of our monitors and set protocol for a cycle. This Gametes and embryos are in artificial environment mimicking natural environment a stricter control on ph, temperature, air are perhaps most crucial. It is believed and observed that a compromise in any of this parameters does cause detrimental effect on embryos.

Usually laboratories have protocols of checking the incubator settings, media, temperature daily. We do observe success rate to vary routinely. Where a drop in preganacy rate is to be considered more seriously , this makes us ponder over our KPI which should reflect the cause. We have observed many instances but we discuss about three such scenarios which caused damage to our pregnancy rates and KPI helped us.

First Scenario-



opening incubator door frequently


On one occasion we observed more number of patients than usual in a batch of ART, while other KPI parameters were within accepted range. This observation lead to the fact that increased number of patient resulted in increase in number of oocytes.. This means that the load on incubator was much higher than usual. This load can be described by frequent opening of door to make fresh plates , transfer embryos, change media, observe growth, and embryo transfer. We used a conventional front load door incubator. Our KPI did not have a count or time period of incubator door openings, though it was handled to be bare necessity. To establish this assumption few studies observed that, there is a difference in temperature throughout the incubator where front and upper shelf had temperature nearer to 37 c as compared to other locations. Temperature displayed on screen of incubator was just an average. Temperature probe recorded average temperature of inside the incubator and hence KPI recordings were quite stable . However an important study observed that incubator door opened for 5 seconds takes a temperature recovery time of around 20 minutes whereas dishes took 30 minutes to come back to 37c. This can be explained due to cooler air from room entering the incubator and also cold co2 gas being pumped in due to decrease in co2 concentrations. IVF work station also has heating mechanism adjusted to 37 c but even that is average temp. And we do see different tempertaure in different parts of table. Further work station is also cooled by laminar air flow .

Studies have proven that prolonged temperature variations impacts fertilisation especially high temperature affects cytokinesis of embryos. However we did not record absolutely mass failed fertilisation or mass embryo arrest .Though the number was less but the embryos progressed to blastocyst formation and also gave pregnancies. This leads to debate of optimal temperature required for embryo culture. Researchers have proved that core body temperature of reproductive axis to be 1c less than 37c. Interestingly a study observed difference in blastocyst formation from culturing the embryos at 36c .however fertilisation rate and implantation rate at both 36 c and 37 c were similar. With the concept of mimicking natural environment it was observed that preovulatory follicle had 2.3c less temperature than 36c. This could explain why even after temperature fluctuation we could still get good blastocyst as well as implantation. Another possible theory is a temperature regulating mechanism in embryo which remains an interesting research. Temperature fluctuations have an impact on pH also . Considering the importance of temperature and as most study design are carried out at 37c and better success rate at this temperature makes us accept cell culture to be at 37c.

In order to set things right measures were initiated to reduce the number of patients or oocyte in one incubator. On an average not more than 2/3 patient with 6-8 dishes were kept in an incubator. Open culture system was changed to closed culture. Procedures like Dish equilibration, sperm swim up where carried out in mini incubator rather than routine incubators. Another way of controlling this could be use of embryo scope or using single step media or bench top incubators. But we preferred the older method to be cost effective.

Second scenario-



pH of media, calibration of instruments



.

Our KPI includes routine CO2 check by CO2 analyser and they were fairly within accepted range and settings were adjusted depending upon observed value to maintain co2 at 5 % or 6% . this percentage varied according to media manufacturing company like, SAGE needs equilibration at 5 % while vitrolife needs it at 6% . As co2 is used to maintain Ph . Despite being vigilant there was drop in overall blastocyst formation and implantation rate. A study of KPI statistics revealed more or less steady co2 and temperature with no changes in protocols . A detailed study questioned co2 analyser observation and it was found that co2 analyser was not serviced or calibrated over 6 months.

Investigations confirmed Co2 analyser reading to be faulty. This scenario explains a lot about calibration of our instrument which are meant to check and control our functioning instruments like incubator.Routinely a calibration tolerance of 0.1 was accepted by us. We were using colourless media( vitrolife) rather than “pink” media ( phenol) hence changes in ph of media were unnoticed. literature supports ph to be most crucial for gamates. Routinely a ph of media scaling of 7.2-7.4 is accepted for cell culture. ph of media is also very dynamic and influenced by temperature,co2, volume of media. This leads to debate of optimal ph of media. Studies have revealed variable ph,that is alkaline in oviduct and acidic in uterus. Oocytes also showed varied ph from Germinal vesical stage ( 7.04 +/- 0.07) to MII stage ( 6.98 +/- 0.010). while amphibian oocytes shows rise in pH during fertilisation but unseen in humans. This opens a theory of intracellular ph regulatory system to maintain optimal Ph as required . This balance of CO

2

and HCO

3

in media sets the extracellular ph(ph

e

) while intracelluarly (pHi) HCO

3




/Cl



ad Na

+

/H

+

regulatory systems maintain stability in cell. This self regulatory system of embryos seems to maintain the balance inspite of fluctuations and hence we see blastocyst formation and even implantation rates. Oocytes maintain their pHi through combination of follicular fluid, granulose cells. Hence denuded oocyte are more vulnearble and depends only up on pHe of media. Studies observed that raising ph to 7.4 or lowering to 6.8 affected the embryo metabolism where alkalinine media caused more damage. Thus ph around 7.2 seems to be more stabilising. Studies have observed ph irregularities to affect actin, cytoskeletal elements, meiotic spindle, cell apoptosis, mitochondria position in embryo.

This problem was addressed by calibrating our co2 analyser every 3 months. Media tubes should be capped off immediately after opening to prevent evaporation which can cause ph fluctuation.KPI included servicing dates of each instruments with due date notifications.” Pink media” was not used considering toxicity of phenol and above all in subsequent cycles pregnancy rates were up with above correction.

Should Novice Nurses Work In Critical Care Area Nursing Essay

Choosing a nursing career is very challenging; because we take the responsibility of ones life. A nurse has to be competent enough and hard worker, but the critical care nurse should be more skillful and critical thinker, because they directly provide care to critically ill patients. Critical care areas have high tech monitoring, patient status changes continuously. Therefore staff needs to be experienced however for the novice nurse the environment is very new and they don’t acquire enough skills. In critical care areas staff should be quick responder because patient’s condition deteriorates within minutes. Staff needs to respond quickly otherwise the patient may suffer. (Morrison et al. 2001).Critical care areas are designed to give care to especially critically ill patients. Critical care nurses are persons who provide care to those patients who are with life threatening problems and at high risk. The new graduate nurses are not able to provide their excellence of service because they have lack of experience, lack of communication skills, and chances of error increase.

Firstly, they are fresh graduates and have lack of experience. They directly came from school; just after graduation so they have deficit in clinical knowledge and they also don’t know the policies. Their skills are not well developed due to which they are at high risk to make mistakes. They are not practical because they have not encountered critical patients in reality. So if patient have any internal deterioration in condition they are unable to understand or recognize it. According to Ihlenfeld (2005) “When coming directly from nursing school and starting their careers in the critical care area, new nurses are able to start without preconceived ideas about nursing care. However, they bring with them inexperience, lack of personal confidence in their own abilities, and the need for professional reassurance.” I want to share an experience that in unit I was team leader and due to lack of experienced staff I assigned a novice nurse in special care area. I was too busy so, after three hours I got the chance to assess her practice. I entered in the room and I observed that one patient’s heart rate was very high. When I asked her about the patient’s condition that staff said that monitor leads are not well secured, but I had some doubt. I went to the patient and checked manual pulse which was too high. Suddenly, patient developed arrhythmias then I called doctor and we managed the patient. After that event, I realized that novice cannot work in critical care areas. According to Morrison et al. (2001) Seven hundred and thirty five reports covering 1,472 incidents were identified as relating to nurse staff inexperience. “Nurse Staff inexperience can have a negative impact on the quality of care delivered to critically ill patients, as shown by the occurrence and outcome of incidents related to such inexperience Errors are more likely to occur when inexperienced staff is combined with staff shortage, inadequate supervision and high unit activity”.

Secondly, novice nurses don’t have effective communication skills. They did not have worked individually in hospital setup, so their Interpersonal skills are not well developed. They face many problems while communicating with other health care workers, patients and their families properly. According to the critical care nurse “Physicians demand information, co-workers are stressed, families are frightened, and patients feel helpless. Therefore, it is essential for the nurse to practice strong interpersonal dynamics both verbally and nonverbally and to stimulate optimistic health team communications” this lack of impersonal skill decrease nurse’s involvement in patient’s care. Moreover, they are very new so, they try to discuss patients more for their learning purpose and this will break patient’s confidentiality and privacy.

Thirdly, critical care nurses should be competent and manage their work on time. On the other hand novice nurse need much time for a simple task, because of that they get overwhelmed even with very few tasks. Due to workload they get confused, and become anxious, and get frustrated easily and unable to manage their work on time which increases chances of error. Sometime these errors can become sentinel and can put the patient’s life in danger. Furthermore, they have lack of self-confidence due to new working environment. It’s better to first assign them in ward setup to bring competence and build confidence in them. According to Proulx & Bourcier (2008) “Graduate nurses are often overwhelmed with the multiple roles and tasks required in caring for critical care patients. The preceptors at Catholic Medical Center, Manchester, New Hampshire, identified a major concern with graduate nurses: too much time was required for the new nurses to become proficient at completing basic critical care tasks.” I have observed that due to some reasons like increasing nursing workload, and high nursing turnover, absenteeism rates and staff shortages or not having senior staff we assign novice nurses in critical area. Moreover, due to lack of experience and skills practices they cannot make proper decisions, and are unable to manage patients which increase the patient stay in hospital.

According to Morrison et al. (2001) “Nurses in intensive care are continually challenged with monitoring patients, making decisions and responding in a timely manner to make changes in patient condition. The nurse’s ability to make accurate clinical judgments is crucial”. However, inexperienced nurses may be unprepared for the demands of intensive care nursing, requiring extra support and supervision.”

We can take the example of our hospital; our management has taken the decision they don’t hire the novice nurses in critical care area.

Yes, this is very right that novice has lack of experience, not competent, and don’t have communication skills, but they can work in critical care area, for the reason that they are fresh graduates, subsequently can bring new changes with their new knowledge as they are up to date with new information and strategies to management patient . Work in critical care area is very important for their growth, professional development, and their learning. Furthermore, Skills and knowledge come with experience, and experience also make person competent and confidence. They should be allowed to work in critical care areas. In addition, hospital should arrange the sessions and learning programs for them to make them more competent. Unit management needs to assign novice nurse in critical area with an experienced staff for training and make that staff more competent and aware about environment. According to Ihlenfeld (2005) “To provide new graduates with the education and experience that they need to independently practice in critical care, mentors are recommended to be assigned to new nurses. These role models help the graduate nurse to grow into the critical care role.” When I was working as a staff, in our unit we used to assign novice nurse with senior expert staff for six to eight weeks to train them, before assigning them permanently and individually.

This is true that knowledge competency and confidence come with experience. It is necessary for novice professional growth, but we cannot let to put the patient’s life in danger for one person’s learning. We can teach them initially in general wards. They can first get experience in ward setup and then can be transferred to critical care areas. Since they have lack of communication abilities consequently, they cannot communicate effectively with patient, and which hinders repo building between nurses and patient hence cannot help patients. Experienced staff can perform these tasks very accurately.

All in all Novice nurse should not be allowed to work in critical care area, because they have lack of experience, don’t have communication skills, are not competent to work in critical care area and help patients to cope with this uncertain situation. Lastly, I would recommend that they should be first assign in general wards for their professional growth, skill practices, and to increase the knowledge.

Proulx, D. M., & Bourcier, B. J. (2013). GraduateNurses in the Intensive Care Unit: An Orientation Model.

Reducing Inequalities in Healthcare


Background

Equity in health and reducing inequalities are considered as the main goals of all health systems (1) which is the absence of systematic disparities in health or in the social determinants of health between social groups with different levels of social advantage(2). Health inequalities are structural and systematic differences in health status between and within social groups in society. There is a difference between the inequality and inequity in health so that inequity is regarded as avoidable inequalities (3). The term “health inequity” has been recognized as a root cause affecting health and is closely related to “social determinants of health (SDH)” including place of residence, race/ethnicity/culture/language, occupation, gender/sex, religion, education, socioeconomic status, and social capital requirements. Inequity in health is more important than other inequities because the health is the first prerequisite to achieve other capacities(4,5). Studies, for example, show that the richer individuals are healthier than the poorer ones(6). However inequalities do exist in health care (notably in access to care), they should not be considered as the principal cause of inequity in health status(7).

In response to growing concern over the continuation and expansion of these inequalities, the World Health Organization Commission on Social Determinants of Health was established and made recommendations to develop and systematically monitor the equity in health and social determinants of health at the local, national and international levels. They may lead to design appropriate interventions and facilitate evidence-informed policy-making process(8).

Monitoring health inequalities through producing appropriate evidence can promote accountability and continuously improve equity-oriented health plans including moving toward universal health coverage(9). Given the importance of the issue, various countries have initiated the development of such surveillance systems(10). Health equity surveillance systems include the analysis of groups in terms of socio-economic status, age, gender, race, ethnicity, residence and other key factors determining socio-economic advantages or disadvantages (11)

The above list of factors identified may not include the underlying causal factors and pathways of health inequality from the developing countries perspective. As there are differences from country to country, addressing health inequalities may need country-specific indicators. Identifying causal factors at country level is essential for prioritizing policy interventions (12).

The accurate selection of appropriate indicators can affect the proper and reliable measurement of inequality rate. General important considerations for selection the indicators include the cost of data collection, data quality issues, availability of data for monitoring at proper time intervals, cultural appropriateness, sensitivity to the policy interventions and the required technical capacity for the analysis(13, 14).

Some countries use the World Health Organization’ health equity indicators. In Iran, the basis for development of health equity indicators was the Urban HEART (urban health equity assessment and response tool) indicators. Urban HEART, developed by WHO, is a simple tool and guide to identify health inequity in urban areas which was tested in some countries including Tehran (Iran)(15,16).

In this regard, In Iran the responsibility of the development of health equity indicators was delegated to the Ministry of Health and Medical Education. To develop these indicators, several expert meetings were held and 52 indicators were determined using the Urban HEART and after several refinements. Some of these indicators are international and some other are based on the local circumstances of Iran. The indicators have been determined in five domains including health (20 indicators), human and social development (17 indicators), economic development (4 indicators), physical environment and infrastructures (7 indicators) and governance (4 indicators). In addition, appropriate practical classification variables to calculate were determined for each indicator. Data associated with 12 indicators will be collected using survey studies while data related to 40 other indicators will be gathered through the routine data recording system(14). To ensure the enforcement of the health equity indicators, they were announced to the relevant organizations after its approval.

In order to plan for reducing inequalities, stakeholders should have sufficient knowledge and awareness of the issue of the equity in health and its indicators and reach a consensus about the system for monitoring these factors. It is necessary to clarify challenges and consequently relevant scientific and practical solutions can be applied using the international, national and local evidence.


Objectives

Given the importance of awareness of the health equity indicators and its implementation challenges and lack of study in this area in the country, this study aimed to investigate stakeholders’ perspective on equity in health and its 52 indicators in Iran. The results of the study can help policy makers to better understand the issue in order to effectively plan and implement the health equity indicators.


Materials and Methods

In this qualitative study, data were gathered through semi-structured interviews and the review and analysis of relevant documents including meetings minutes, working plans and working progress reports. The interviews were conducted using a topic guide developed according to a literature review and expert opinion. It was pilot tested using interviews with three policy makers and executives and based on their comments it was revised and finalized. The participants were given the information sheet and consent form prior to the interviews. After research ethics committee approval, interviews conducted in-person on a one-to-one basis after consent was provided by the research director and two trained colleagues. All interviews were recorded and later transcribed verbatim. A framework analytical approach was used for data analysis.

Participants were selected using purposive sampling method and were policy makers involved in developing the indicators and executives responsible for implementing and calculating the indicators. A total of 23 individuals were invited, 8 of whom refused to take part in the study for various work-related reasons or the lack of willingness to participate. There were five policy makers and 10 executives. Among the executives, two were governors of major cities. Interviews continued until data saturation was reached and no new code was found.

The focus of the policy makers’ interview questions was primarily on the process of indicators development and participation and interaction of various sectors in this process the developing indicators as well as steps of indicators development process. Executives answered questions mainly regarding their perception of the health equity and related indicators’ calculation and implementation processes.

The member check strategy was used and the comments were incorporated in the final analysis. It helped to ensure that the findings were congruent with participants’ perceptions, beliefs and opinions. All the stages in the study were recorded to make it possible to track of each stage and clarify the procedures.


Discussion

The equity and equity in health are not only the issue of international interest but also have been considered in Iran development plans. Furthermore, committee on social determinants of health in the final report from the World Health Organization (2008) titled “closing the gap in a generation” emphasized on national and global health equity surveillance systems for routine monitoring of health inequity(8).

The issue of stewardship in health equity is a matter of great importance. Health system need to lead by taking a stewardship role in supporting a cross-government approach that focuses on the social determinants of health and performing as catalysts to all society. The Health in All Policies programs of the European Unionand South Australia promote inter-sectoral collaborations to health equity (17). The establishment of a common language for health sector and other agencies is considered as an important challenge in its leadership. Gopalan et al. suggested that a lack of awareness among stakeholders restricted the inter-sectoral convergence on combating health inequities(18).

In Iran, the Ministry of Health is the steward of health equity goals and it is suggested that a secretariat or an independent office be established for health equity.

According to the definitions of equity concepts provided by the stakeholders, the difference between viewpoints is obvious and their perceptions on the main concepts of equity in health are different from each other. This study showed that many executives and some policy makers disagreed on key concepts of equity in health and the executives had insufficient information about the concept of equity in health as desired by the policy makers. In general, many executives considered the equity in health mainly as fair access to and distribution of health system resources. Also, Low study showed that access to health services alone is not sufficient to achieve equity in health(19). However city governors and medical science universities are executives responsible for implementing the indicators in the region, they lack sufficient attitudes and awareness towards the issue of equity in health. It seems that orientation programs by the Ministry of Health should be more comprehensive and with an aim of emphasizing a higher priority of the issue for executives. The establishment of these indicators requires capacity building, training and shifting the attitudes of the executives implementing this program. So training and improving the awareness of the key actors are main effective steps for the establishment of health equity indicators. Training and improving the awareness of executives are facilitated by providing regulatory requirements helping the decision-making.

Beheshtian et al suggested that the Consensus-Oriented Decision-Making (COMD) model for more intersectoral collaboration and consensus among other areas can be used in Iran (14). After the development of the indicators and in the establishment step, interaction between politicians, policy makers and regulatory authorities is essential in order to establish these indicators.

There are some challenges regarding the calculation of the health equity indicators in the country. However 40 out of 52 health equity Indicators are collected through routine system, investigation and survey are needed for remaining 12 indicators. The routine system itself needs to be reformed and improved including hardware and software improvements. Furthermore, the preparation and participation of organizations to change their statistics and reporting systems are also required. Therefore, gaining a wide intra and intersectoral participation is needed to collect data for the indicators and change statistical forms. This participation should be established at levels of policy makers and high authority officials.

In addition to the above mentioned issues, creating the infrastructure for electronic data recording and defining access level may help to the establishment of the indicators.

The establishment of indicators requires financing, training and empowerment of organizations employees, legal requirements, and finally a clear action plan. A report from the Pan American Health Network on the development of health equity indicators in Canada also cited the similar challenges such as the need for financial resources, being time consuming as well as limitation of sources of information (20).

As the establishment of the indicators is in its the primary steps, so the executives responsible for implementing the indicators have not had the possibility for complete and necessary adaptation to ministry of health instructions and gaining more support for the executives, training them as well as laying the proper groundwork for calculation these indicators are obviously necessary.

It is debatable whether these indicators show the extent of the health equity in the country. Many policymakers stated that the World Health Organization and international indicators provided the basis for the country indicators but some changes were made in them according to cultural and social conditions of the country. In this regard, an important point mentioned by the policy makers is that as these indicators had not previously been identified, so the development of them can be considered as a positive step and they will be revised in the future according to feedbacks from universities and other organizations. Braveman in his study argued that data utilization to develop interventions is far more important than data collection itself(2). The results of this study are in consistent with those of current study, because many policy makers argued that the establishment of these indicators can be helpful if appropriate interventions are developed based on information they provide. It is, therefore, necessary to specify solutions for using the indicators in decision making. Policy making for reducing inequity in health is too difficult because it is an intersectoral policy making requiring various areas and organizations involvement and this, in turn, demands the specification of common goals, integrated accountability and increased organizational responsibilities (14).

Overall, the results of the study showed the inadequate awareness of stakeholders on equity in health, lack of proper infrastructure and insufficient support from stakeholders are the important challenges regarding the establishment of the indicators; these findings are consistent with those of a study by Gopalan et al(18).

Limited access to some policy makers and executives was a limitation. A small number of the governors and executives were interviewed while there were more policy makers and stakeholders participating in the development of the indicators.

Conclusion: As the establishment of the indicators is in its the primary steps, so the executives responsible for implementing the indicators have not had the possibility for complete and necessary adaptation to ministry of health instructions and gaining more support for the executives, training them as well as laying the proper groundwork for calculation these indicators are obviously necessary. The development of the indicators requires a shared understanding among policy makers and executives. As the attention has been focused recently on the issue, in addition to knowledge improvement, proper solutions with intersectional collaboration approach in order to tackle challenges should be considered.


Related content


References:

1. Murray CJ, Frenk JA. Framework for assessing the performance of health systems. Bull World Health Organ 2000; 78(6):717-31.

2. Braveman P, Gruskin S. Defining equity in health. J Epidemiol Community Health 2003; 517:254-8.

3. Whitehead M. Whitehead M. The concepts and principles of equity and health. Int J Health Serv 1992;22(3):429-45.

4. Marmot, M. Achieving health equity: from root causes to fair outcomes. The Lancet 2007;370(9593): 1153-63.

5. O’Neill J, Tabish H, Welch V, Petticrew M, Pottie K, Clarke M, et al. Applying an equity lens to interventions: using PROGRESS ensures consideration of socially stratifying factors to illuminate inequities in health.J Clin Epidemiol 2014;67(1):56-64.

6. Exworthy M, Blane D, Marmot M. Tackling health inequalities in the United Kingdom: the progress and pitfalls of policy. Health Serv Res 2003; 38(6 Pt 2): 1905–22.

7. Davidson R, Kitzinger J, Hunt K. The wealthy get healthy, the poor get poorly? Lay perceptions of health inequalities. Soc Sci Med 2006; 62(9):2171-82.

8. Commission on Social Determinants of Health. Closing the Gap in a Generation: Health Equity through Action on the Social Determinants of Health. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2008 .Available at:

http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2008/9789241563703_eng.pdf

9. Hosseinpoor AR, Victora CG, Bergen N, Barros AJ, Boerma, T. Towards universal health coverage: the role of within-country wealth-related inequality in 28 countries in sub-Saharan Africa. Bull World Health Organ 2011; 89(12): 881-889.

10. Cristina C, Caroline C. Can we build on existing information systems to monitor health inequities and the social determinants of health in the EU? Brussels: Euro Health Net, 2010.

11. Kelly PM, A. Bonnefoy J, Butt J, Bergman V. The social determinants of health: developing an evidence base for political action. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2007.

12. Eshetu, EB, Woldesenbet SA. Are there particular social determinants of health for the world’s poorest countries?.Afr Health Sci. Mar 2011; 11(1): 108–115

13. Wirth M, Delamonica E, Sacks E, Balk D, Storeygard A, Minujin A. Monitoring health equity in the MDGs: a practical guide. Center for International Earth Science Information Network, 2006.

14. Beheshtian M, Manesh AO, Bonakdar SH, Afzali HM, Larijani B, Hosseini L, et al. Intersectoral Collaboration to Develop Health Equity Indicators in Iran. . Iran J Public Health 2013;42(1):31-5.

15. Asadi-Lari M, Vaez-Mahdavi MR, Faghihzadeh S, Montazeri A, Farshad AA, Kalantari N, et al. The application of urban health equity assessment and response tool (Urban HEART) in Tehran; concepts and framework Med J Islam Repub Iran 2010;24(3):175-85.

16. Asadi-Lari M, Vaez-Mahdavi MR, Faghihzadeh S, Cherghian B, Esteghamati A, Farshad A. Response-oriented measuring inequalities in Tehran: second round of Urban Health Equity Assessment and Response Tool (Urban HEART-2), concepts and framework. Med J Islam Repub Iran 2013;27(4): 236-48.

17. Baum F.E, Bégin M, Houweling T.A, Taylor S. Changes not for the fainthearted: reorienting health care systems toward health equity through action on the social determinants of health. Am J Public Health. 2009; 99(11): 1967–74.

18. Gopalan SS, Mohanty S, Das A. Challenges and opportunities for policy decisions to address health equity in developing health systems: case study of the policy processes in the Indian state of Orissa. Int J Equity Health 2011; 10(1):55.

19. Low A, Ithindi T, Low A. A step too far? Making health equity interventions in Namibia more sufficient. Int J Equity Health 2003; 2(1):5.

20. Pan-Canadian Public Health Network. Indicators of Health Inequalities. Pan-Canadian Public Health Network. Pan-Canadian Public Health Network. [cited 2014 Sep 24]; Available from: URL:

http://www.phn-rsp.ca/pubs/ihi-idps/pdf/Indicators-of-Health-Inequalities-Report-PHPEG-Feb-2010-EN.pdf


Acknowledgements

The authors would thank people who participated in this study and Iran University of Medical Sciences for financial support.


Financial Disclosure

There is not any conflict of interests.


Funding/Support

This work was supported by Iran University of Medical sciences [IUMS/SHMIS-15748].


Authors’ Contributions

Ravaghi and Oliyaee Manesh jointly designed the study. Arabloo and Goshtaei collected the data. Ravaghi, Goshtaei and Oliyaee Manesh contributed to data analysis and interpretation of the results. Arabloo, Goshtaei and Abolhassani prepared the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Analyze and provide at least two reasons why implementing Medicaid managed care is so complex. Identify at least two trends that you feel have a great impact on managed health care today. Discuss the effect these trends have on managed care.

Analyze and provide at least two reasons why implementing Medicaid managed care is so complex.
Identify at least two trends that you feel have a great impact on managed health care today.
Discuss the effect these trends have on managed care.

Identify at least two trends that you feel have a great impact on managed health care today.
Discuss the effect these trends have on managed care.
Explain how these trends will continue to influence managed care in the future.
Evaluate the potential impact on government and state sponsored, Medicare and Medicaid programs.
Analyze and provide at least two reasons why implementing Medicaid managed care is so complex.

Design a roadmap using the DMAIC methodology to outline the project.

Design a roadmap using the DMAIC methodology to outline the project.

 

Lean Sigma Roadmap

Post a response to the following:
In your role as a nursing administrator, you plan to begin a project to change a process in your organization. Using the Lean Sigma roadmap approach, design a roadmap using the DMAIC methodology to outline the project.

use this book.

Wedgwood, I. (2015). Lean Sigma: Rebuilding capability in heathcare. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall,Retrevied from https://phoenix.vitalsource.com/books/9781323174203/id/ch01